Tuesday, May 09, 2006

Boarding the Ark

Let me tell you a story.
Once, in a time and place that now seems as remote and unfathomable as any long-lost Atlantis, I trained as a medieval musicologist. A rigorous and thorough preparation for a life very different than mine. That's not the story. But that distant far-off place is where I learned this story, by reading the lines and what lies between them.

In a smallish town, many years ago, there lived a man called Noe. He had a wife and some married sons. There's no point in asking his wife's name - no-one remembers it. This town was perhaps a little licentious. On special occasions it's possible that it could even have been described as libidinous. Noe - most assuredly a virtuous man - certainly thought so. Often he could be seen moping about and grumbling into his beard about the `youth of today' and `sinks of iniquity.'

Evidently Noe wasn't alone in his opinions, for after a few years of moping he began building a sizeable boat. The town being fairly well inland, it would be fair to say that this attracted some local attention. Noe told all who asked - and many did - that God planned on flooding the entire Earth and drowning everyone, since the youth of today were simply not up to scratch, the whole place was a sink of iniquity and thoroughly libidinous to boot. Only he and his family were to be saved.

It's unclear whether Noe started out thinking that only he and his family were to be saved, or whether his sceptical reception from inquirers led him to this view.

His wife rolled her eyes and did her best to ignore the sounds of sawing and hammering. She did her best not to see the thick layer of wood-dust that settled on everything as fast as she could wipe it. She went about her business as usual, selling her goods in the market, meeting with her friends and sharing the news of the town. Perhaps she spent less time than usual at home, but in this she was alone within her family. For the sons had been roped into sawing and hammering, and the daughters-in-law were occupied with tending an ever-increasing menagerie whose yammering and clamouring threatened to outdo even the noise of construction.

And then the rains came. At first this was a welcome break in the dry season, a chance for the wells to be replenished, an omen of a good harvest free from drought. But they did not stop.

And Noe's wife looked at the ark and at her husband's barely disguised glee at the prospect of divine retribution.

The rains continued. People retreated to the highest ground within the town, to the rises, the hillocks, the roofs. All crowded together, people grew sick from strange illnesses and died, especially the very old and the very young.

Noe's boat began to float.

And here is where the story diverges. In the usual version, Noe's wife gets on board like a good little girl, leaving her friends, their children, her relatives and all to drown. On the ark, she floats for forty days and forty nights. Eventually one of my namesakes is released, disappears for a few days before flapping back with an olive branch.

But in some much later versions - plays enacted in England's wealthier market towns in the later middle ages - the tale is told a little bit differently.

In one, Noe's wife refuses to board the ark. Then, feeling the water at her feet, her courage fails her and she runs aboard.

In yet a different version, she and her friends are gathered before the ark. She refuses to board unless they too are saved. Noe forces her aboard and leaves her friends to drown.

At the time these plays were performed, Noe's wife was understood as a comic character - an example of the vice-filled, contrary wife. Her refusal to board the ark is meant to be funny. Whether through her own cowardice, or a lack of physical strength, her rebellion is so easily undone. But to me, peering at her this way and that through my mis-matched eyes, Noe's nameless wife does not seem so very funny.

For left to my own devices, virtue and vice should be assigned quite differently.



Afterword
This is another old diary, this time from BT. I've been thinking about Noah's wife a bit lately, so thought I'd repost it.

13 Comments:

Blogger dove said...

Thankyou DTF, flattery will get you everywhere ;)

So when is your latest debate going to go on Left Hand of the Dial? Inquiring minds need to know . . .

5/10/2006 8:27 pm  
Blogger dove said...

What's the lula/lulu route Nanette?

Yes, that fable always left me cold as well. As a kid I had an illustrated Children's Bible with wonderfully painted and surprisingly graphic pictures and I think my sense that there's something wrong with that story comes from that book.

5/13/2006 1:54 am  
Blogger dove said...

Hmm. This is going to sound like false modesty fishing for compliments, but it's not. I'm asking for a calm judicious eye, or at least I hope I am.

It's true that writing has become increasingly important to me over the last couple of years (though what with one thing and another I've always been writing in one or another capacity and language has always been something I take seriously).

But I used to play violin and I eventually reached what one might call the 'semi-pro' stage, where one expects to get paid fairly well for playing (but doesn't not make one's whole living from it). During that period, I realised that there is a world of difference between a good amateur and a good professional -- possibly because I was neatly sandwiched between those two worlds. Different standards and criteria apply.

I think I'm a reasonably good writer. I work quite hard at it and I don't generally post things unless I think I've written what I meant and meant what I've written. That's why rather few of my postings are topical.

Since I started posting to blogs I've become more confident about putting what I write out there for people to see. And it is clear that what I write finds some readers who think well of it, which pleases me enormously. But what I don't have is a sense of, I guess, is whether or not it measures up on that professional set of scales.

"O wad some powr the Giftie gie us. to see oursels as ithers see us"

Completely OT, I've decided not to put Let's Talk about Alex on BT. I'm writing something different for there, which will link to it. I reread a lot of the stories around the cartoon fiasco last night (a depressing but very informative way of spending an evening) and I think I need to say something that is unambiguously about power relations and solidarity. And white women. Knowing me it will take a couple of days.

5/14/2006 8:48 pm  
Blogger dove said...

(Rolls eyes) -- "but doesn't not make one's whole living from it."

That should be "but doesn't make one's whole living from it."

Evidently the irony bug is going around at the moment -- beware!

5/14/2006 9:03 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

From poco:

I agree with Nanette and DTF--you do have an amazing skill with words. Your tales remain in my mind days after I have read them, and they compel re-readings--always a good sign, I think.

I am still chewing over the one where people intervene in the past (against all rules) to save lives. Cant find it on this site, because I would like to read it again--also the one with Victoria's statues coming to life.

Re the professional set of scales--I am not sure whether publishing works the same way as music does--perhaps it does I just don't know. In my mind, the difference between, as you put it, a good amateur and a good professional, would be obvious/audible? to people in the music business. I think that in writing things are not so clear-cut--see the amount of bilge that gets published regularly. :-)

Tastes vary enormously. That said, however, I would urge you to try and hook a publisher.

5/15/2006 7:58 pm  
Blogger dove said...

Hmmm. Well, thankyou (she says blushing a bit since she said she wasn't fishing for compliments and she now feels well and truly complimented). I might start thinking through how to dip my toes in that particular pond then. (Especially since, if I can make myself be disciplined about it, I might actually have a longer story drafted by the end of summer. I should probably go do katiebird's site to keep myself on track with it).

Poco -- An Experiment should be under the archived posts, in March I think? And I'll pop A Shortish Story up now.

Completely OT can you get into the comments on DTF and Duke 1676's fabulous debate? I can't seem to today (it's Haloscan's turn to be wondering why I'm not giggling delightedly!) -- if you can, could I get you to do me a huge favour cut and post them here for me, since I really want to see folks comments (Feel a bit like a kid with their ear pressed up to a thick door lol).

5/15/2006 8:24 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi dove,
Archives! (slaps hand to head) Thanks for A Shortish Story.

Cut and pasted the whole, including a spammer at the end.:)
poco
**************

Wow! Not sure what I should sink my teeth into: the food or the debate? There are succulent morsels to be gleaned from either.

At some level, I would have to say that both Duke and Ductape have an overly rosy vision of the future. Taking over the empty shell of the Democratc party and transforming it from the bottom up so that it responds to the peoples' higher aspirations---not gonna happen.

Not just because fat cats controlling the Party will not let it happen, but peoples' higher aspirations are easily satisfied with empty promises and shell games. A tiny little benefit which does nothing to change the structural injustices is enough to get most higher-aspiration-people to abort their movements and their list of demands.
A revolution--not gonna happen either. As Ductape says you have to be in a place where you know that whatever you do you will die, before you are willing to put your body and your rented apt. and your job that puts the meals on your table, and your family and your tv on the line. Too miniscule a number of people in that situation right now to make any sort of revolution feasible.
Its all going to be more of the same--at least during my life-time. 30 years hence, when I would have crossed the three-score and ten mark...hmmmm...who knows?
poco | 05.14.06 - 7:45 pm | #
------------------------------------------------------------------------

I don't know, poco. I think there are two things that occur to me in thinking about this which are sort of contradictory.

The first is relatively optimistic: revolution is not only the province of the dying. The point at which people say 'enough' is not always beyond that of no return. And I think that -- like many things that appear organic and effortless on their surface -- there's work goes on persuading people that enough is enough. Beneath that swan's graceful glide are feet paddling furiously.

The second contradictory thought is also optimistic in an odd sort of way.
" once you reach a critical level of certainty that you will die whether you do what I want you to do or not, I have lost all my negotiating chips."
At the end of Neil Gaiman's Preludes and Nocturnes there's a famous episode (which arguably marks the beginning of the series proper, which if you have not read you should) in which Death and Dream meet up, throw some bread at some pigeons (Death also throws some bread at Dream, who deserves it)and then go on a walk around town together. At one point Death is standing in front of a wall on which is written: "Noone gets out of here alive."

And nobody does, do they? Long term personal survival is not actually one of the goodies on offer -- short-term survival, yes, but not long-term survival. And if personal survival is off the table, (that is, if one doesn't harbour the secret belief that one will live forever), then the picture is arguably a bit rosier for things like solidarity than if it were.
Hmmm. Delany wrote a brilliant essay on this very subject as the preface to A Game of You and I want to quote from it except I can't because I don't have a copy handy. But hie ye to your nearest bookshop.
And thank you both for a brilliantly-written debate.
dove | Homepage | 05.14.06 - 9:09 pm | #
------------------------------------------------------------------------

Funny, I was just having a conversation with my wife, and I mentioned - much to her sheer amazement - that I'm actually a fairly hopeful person about the future. How a person with a pessimistic temperament could do that is another story for another time, but I digress.
I'm hopeful when I see that someone managed to read a long, well-written, and thought-out conversation and bothered to comment on it. I certainly felt hopeful when I realized that even in my isolated corner of the nation that there were demonstrations in solidarity with our immigrants. Cautiously hopeful, but hopeful nonetheless.
And I'm certainly quite pleased to see DTF taking my open invitation to post stuff on this blog at face value, and hope that he, Duke, and Manito will feel free to continue doing so.
James | Homepage | 05.15.06 - 3:20 am | #
------------------------------------------------------------------------

First let me make it clear that any typos are my fault. Duke tried to take them out, and it is possible that although I did save the corrected one, I may have inadvertantly put the one with the typos back in.

poco, it is not that I disagree with your premise, just that I think that the situation has already become more extreme than many realize, and continues hurtling in that direction without significant obstacle.

In the case of migrants in the US, as I say somewhere in that vast sea of words, they want a card. I do not think that shell games will do it. These are not Estadosunidenses. And the effectiveness may be running out, at least in some segments, even with Estadosunidenses. Although they are culturally, at least in theory, willing to accept that the death of grandma because they could not pay the mortgage and buy her pills is a necessary sacrifice in the war on terror, and the underclass have certainly led the way in accepting deaths of loved ones so that rich men can have more money, I'm not sure the entitlement classes will go as quietly.

LOL dove, although as usual, you bring intriguing and thoughtful references to books I either have not read or do not remember having read enough to discuss them, unless I am mistaken, you get it. Revolution is optimistic in some situations, and this is one if there ever was one. :D

James, thank you for your kind generosity in granting me the privilege of weighting down your blog with this behemoth, and I agree it lifts my heart to see people who are willing to actually read the thing.
I thought of appending some sort of Cliff Notes version, just to make it more accessible, but I just couldn't manage to sift it down. This will come as a surprise to no one.
DuctapeFatwa | Homepage | 05.15.06 - 5:58 am | #
------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hey,
Just brought coin from americanidolcoin.com which will feature 2 finalists on 2 sides! Price just $14.95 get yours at americanidolcoin.com
C ya.
Flip | 05.15.06 - 6:12 am | #
------------------------------------------------------------------------

5/15/2006 9:20 pm  
Blogger dove said...

DTF, fear not -- it did go on James's blog (which I must get organised and link to!). It's just that Haloscan and I are having a new philosophical disagreement (I think Haloscan should let me see comments: Haloscan doesn't) -- so poco very kindly resposted the comments from your and Duke's debate here.

5/16/2006 7:03 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Only for community wingeddove.blogspot.com! HOT! Out of stock
1.Buy Tramadol (Generic Ultram) with no prior prescription, overnight delivery, COD orders accepted. Shipped from a licensed U.S. pharmacy
2.Buy 10 100mg Sildenafil Citrate tablets for only $45, 30 tablets only $90, and 60ct only $150. Worldwide shipping only $10. Plus get 20% free pills on future orders. Also soft tabs and oral jelly.

1/03/2007 7:30 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Only for community wingeddove.blogspot.com! HOT! Out of stock
1.$99.95 Tramadol 50mg 180 Tablets
2.Looking for Viagra? Check Out our Catalog with the Best Sites Offering Viagra.

1/12/2007 9:12 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Only for community wingeddove.blogspot.com! HOT! Out of stock
1.US Doctors & Pharmacy. Great Service and Prices. VISA-AMX-DISCOVER-COD-Mastercard FREE FEDEX SHIPPING! SATURDAY DELIVERY(where available)orders in by 3pm ship same day
2.Largest selection online of cheap generic medication. No prior prescriptions required. FREE worldwide shipping.

1/19/2007 9:12 am  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

hi

I want to make insurance automobile
prompt office

2/02/2007 1:42 pm  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Only for community wingeddove.blogspot.com! HOT! Out of stock
1.Cheap TramadolNo Prior Prescription Required. US Based Pharmacy, US Licensed Doctors, Free Online Consultation. Fedex Overnight Shipping.
2.Generic Viagra from Licensed online pharmacy No prescription needed 20% Free pills on reorders

2/06/2007 8:18 pm  

Post a Comment

<< Home